Research updatesSelect an entry to read more
Claimed AI-assisted Diophantine definition of the integers in the rationals, with incomplete Lean work
A public repository presents a claimed unconditional construction of a polynomial P intended to characterize q in Z among rational q by existence of rational witnesses. The repository says the original November 5 manuscript used a very large construction, while its currently displayed Version 2 gives an explicit quartic polynomial in 12,504 variables. It records AI-assisted drafting and AI audits, but also explicitly says the Lean development consists of helper modules and that the main bounded-polynomial declaration still contains sorry. This is therefore a potentially important claim about Hilbert's tenth problem over Q, not a completed formal proof or independently certified resolution.
Research relevance:
If correct, a Diophantine definition of Z in Q would be a major result in logic and number theory. The repository is unusually candid about the difference between finite computational checks, AI review, partial formalization, and certification; that distinction is useful for evaluating AI-assisted research workflows.
- Claim status:
- Announcement and public artifact available. The repository claims an unconditional proof and reports scoped AI reviews and finite checks, but explicitly reports no completed Lean formalization of the main theorem and no independent human peer review. An independent expert event page about the separate OpenAI Unique Games claim does not scrutinize this result.
- Limitations:
- The primary artifact is self-published and its current Version 2 update has no clearly stated original publication date, so the item date refers to the repository's stated November 5 manuscript, not to the later version. The identity of the person behind the externally indexed X post was not independently authenticated. I did not build the repository, run its checks, inspect its entire 148-page manuscript, or verify any cited theorem applications. The claimed proof should not be regarded as established.
Sources & further reading
Coverage and limitations
- Public web research consulted Axiom's official Stacks announcement and formalization site, Harmonic's official Aristotle page, Epoch AI's methodology page, the Academy for the Mathematical Sciences URL, arXiv search results, UT Austin's event page, and the primary GitHub repository for the item below. The Academy URL returned HTTP 403; its report was already covered in the previous edition, and the November 5 X thread was amplification rather than a demonstrated new release.
- The Axiom Stacks announcement is dated 2026-11-04 and was already a previous item. Later Axiom X posts added no checkable mathematical update. Harmonic's November 5 material was product promotion rather than a research artifact. Epoch's ECI update is not sufficiently specific to mathematical research.
- Direct Bluesky collection: xenaproject.bsky.social returned no posts; replies and reposts were excluded and pagination was capped at 300. Direct Mathstodon collection for tao@mathstodon.xyz failed with HTTPError; replies and reposts were excluded and at most 300 posts would have been checked.
- Direct X collection was bounded, excluded replies and reposts, and may include cached posts; API account resolution is not independent identity verification. It returned substantive posts from Scott Armstrong and Thomas Bloom, but these were opinions or discussion of an already-covered Academy report. A post by Alex Kontorovich linked to an Elliot Glazer claim; it was used only as a lead. Direct X access to Glazer's account was not supplied, so no complete Glazer timeline was read.
- No proof was independently checked, no Lean code was executed, and search indexing dates were not treated as publication dates. Public search may have missed unindexed papers, repositories, posts, and account updates.
Requested coverage window: 2026-11-04T21:15:01.435653+01:00 — 2026-11-06T09:15:01.404343+01:00.
Public web research; coverage is not exhaustive. A source link is not a certification of a claim.
Archives 79
- 18 Nov 202606:15:02 CET · 84782938
- 17 Nov 202606:15:01 CET · bc10a455
- 16 Nov 202606:15:01 CET · ff6243cc
- 15 Nov 202606:15:01 CET · 8f0783cd
- 14 Nov 202606:15:01 CET · f6ecb5c1
- 13 Nov 202622:41:06 CET · c719c69a
- 12 Nov 202607:22:28 CET · 61d186f2
- 11 Nov 202606:15:01 CET · 03bd4d6a
- 10 Nov 202606:15:01 CET · eea1045a
- 9 Nov 202606:15:01 CET · 38afc7b5
- 8 Nov 202609:06:58 CET · 955591d7
- 7 Nov 202609:15:01 CET · d4d42c9f
- 6 Nov 202609:15:01 CET · 8c28a311
- 5 Nov 202609:15:01 CET · c45b26e9
- 4 Nov 202609:15:02 CET · f5235bb9
- 3 Nov 202609:15:01 CET · 988dfed6
- 2 Nov 202609:15:01 CET · fb18545b
- 1 Nov 202609:15:01 CET · 6f9f9306
- 31 Oct 202609:15:01 CET · 0de2e6ed
- 30 Oct 202609:15:01 CET · bfe586c7
- 29 Oct 202609:15:02 CET · eb6baab7
- 28 Oct 202609:15:02 CET · 33d24461
- 27 Oct 202609:15:02 CET · 2e02e711
- 25 Oct 202609:15:01 CET · acf899c9
- 24 Oct 202609:15:01 CEST · 83273e55
- 23 Oct 202609:13:07 CEST · 5bf9744c
- 23 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · 6ccbbc7e
- 22 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · 798b79fd
- 21 Oct 202608:00:02 CEST · 9b477733
- 20 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · 75a69a2e
Older editions (49)
- 19 Oct 202609:47:43 CEST · f799c226
- 18 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · b3b4112f
- 17 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · 00aa242d
- 16 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · 32a9e1e6
- 15 Oct 202616:54:47 CEST · f093ad2f
- 13 Oct 202620:25:48 CEST · 6138f010
- 13 Oct 202620:20:11 CEST · caeebf3f
- 13 Oct 202620:16:48 CEST · c28bdb56
- 13 Oct 202616:17:50 CEST · 0b02ca1d
- 12 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · c1a48b74
- 11 Oct 202622:01:57 CEST · 50deb522
- 11 Oct 202608:00:02 CEST · b297cb00
- 10 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · d77941f9
- 9 Oct 202609:13:03 CEST · c4acaaf1
- 9 Oct 202609:13:03 CEST · ab04ecd2
- 9 Oct 202609:13:03 CEST · 1b189d44
- 9 Oct 202608:00:01 CEST · ce20e166
- 8 Oct 202608:19:28 CEST · ab8d0f6f
- 7 Oct 202615:49:06 CEST · f9ce0158
- 6 Oct 2026Retrospective
- 5 Oct 2026Retrospective
- 4 Oct 2026Retrospective
- 3 Oct 2026Retrospective
- 2 Oct 2026Retrospective
- 1 Oct 2026Retrospective
- 30 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 29 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 28 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 27 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 26 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 25 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 24 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 23 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 22 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 21 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 20 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 19 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 18 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 17 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 16 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 15 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 14 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 13 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 12 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 11 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 10 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 9 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 8 Sep 2026Retrospective
- 7 Sep 2026Retrospective